Misclassifying Employees as Independent Contractors ... One of the Most Expensive Mistakes of Them All! Part 1

bottom-link">your customer is satisfied withthe job or not. In
The time comes for every successfulother words, although your customer may notpay
home-based business ownerwhen one person canyou (the independent contractor) because she is
no longer do it all. In the early days ofdissatisfiedwith the work performed by your
yourfledgling business you accepted that not onlyemployees, you must still payyour employees
were you CEO, CFO,because they are not independent contractors
COO, secretary, treasurer and marketing director,-they are your employees and are entitled to be
you also had tobe laborer, receptionist, janitor,paid a fixed wage.
chief cook and bottlewasher. Thatis simply whatIf you are dissatisfied with their work, you can
you have to do when starting out. In fact, I'll betfire them but youcan't decide whether to pay or
youworked harder in your "little home business"withhold their wages based on theend result of
than you ever did inyour former life as corporatethe particular project.
whatever, right? But now the time hascome. YouADVANTAGES OF INDEPENDENT
have successfully taken your business past theCONTRACTORS
initial,maddeningly slow, frustrating start-up phase=> Cost
to the point whereyou're seeing some growth ...As mentioned above, the main advantage of
so much growth in fact that you'refinding it nearindependentcontractors versus employees is cost.
impossible to keep all the balls in the air.You can get the sameor better service from
The time has come to hire some help. OK, butindependent contractors for a lower hourlyrate
what kind of helpdo you need? If it's a secretarythan you can from employees because you don't
receptionist, that's easy. You goout and hirehave toincur all the add-on expenses that go along
yourself a competent employee. But what if it'swith hiring employees.
someoneto carry out specific projects such as=> Equipment and Materials
designing a website for agood customer you justIn addition, you don't have to provide office space
can't service within the timeframe thecustomeror materialsand equipment to independent
needs? What if it's someone to create acontractors. As independentcontractors (who may
marketingprogram to launch your business to thealso go by the terms "freelancers",
masses? What if it's abookkeeper to handle your"consultants", "self-employed", "business owners"
accounts payable, receivable andeverything else inetc.) areself-employed business people, they have
between? The difference between these typestheir own "tools of thetrade". If they're website
ofactivities and our secretary/receptionistdesigners, they have their own officespace,
example is that the formerare all specific projectscomputer and printing equipment. If they're
whereas the latter is not.gardeners,they have their own lawn mower,
When considering whom to hire for your projectwhipper-snipper, wheelbarrowand pruning shears.
work, you have achoice ... hire a full-time or=> Legal Liability
part-time employee or hire anindependentAt law, an employer is vicariously liable for the
contractor. By the time you include all thetorts of his orher employees. This means that if
add-oncosts of hiring an employee (in addition toyou hire an employee gardenerwho accidentally
wages or salary you needto add on federal andruns over your customer's pet cat in the
state payroll taxes, social security tax,federaldrivewayof her home when the customer had
unemployment insurance tax, statemade it clear that youremployees are always to
unemploymentinsurance, workers' comp premiumspark in the street, in addition to suing
and employee benefits,not to mention shelling outyouremployee for negligence, she can also sue
for office space and equipment), hiringanyou, the employer, asyou are vicariously
employee becomes a relatively expensive optionresponsible for the acts of your employees.
compared tohiring an independent contractor to(And,by the way, this applies whenever your
do the same work. The add-oncosts of hiring anemployee is acting withinthe scope of
employee usually add about 30-40% to thebill. Inemployment, whether under your express
other words, if you pay your employee $10 aninstructionor not. If your employee has a car
hour, you'llreally be paying $13 - $14 an hour onceaccident when traveling betweenjobs and his
you include all the add-onexpenses.negligence at least partially caused the
In contrast, although you usually pay anaccident,you're responsible to the same extent as
independent contractormore than an employee,the employee.)
that cost will still be less than an employeewithThis is generally not the case with an independent
the add-on expenses. You may pay ancontractor unlessthe independent contractor has
independent contractorbeen engaged to perform an inherentlydangerous
$12 an hour without any additional charges. Soundactivity (such as blasting) or you have attempted
good? Well,read on. It's not as easy as it looks.todelegate to your independent contractor a
WHAT IS AN INDEPENDENT CONTRACTOR?non-delegable duty (suchas keeping a rental
So, what is the difference between an employeeproperty you own in good repair for the benefit
and an independentcontractor anyway? Quiteofthe tenant).
simply, an independent contractor issomeone whoIn addition to minimizing legal liability for torts, hiring
contracts with someone else to provideindependentcontractors also minimizes your liability
specifiedservices for a set price on terms andfor other types of lawsuitssuch as wrongful
conditions outlined in thecontract.termination or job discrimination.
For example, let's say you hire a gardener toDISADVANTAGES OF INDEPENDENT
mow your lawn andget rid of weeds once aCONTRACTORS
week. Your contract (whether written or not)isThere are two main disadvantages to hiring
that Joe Gardener will arrive at your house onindependent contractorsversus employees.
Friday morning,mow your lawn, get rid of weeds=> Misclassification
and generally tend to your garden.Far and away the most serious disadvantage is if
In exchange, you agree to pay Joe $40 for thisyou misclassifyemployees as independent
service each week.contractors. Merely labeling a worker asan
Joe supplies his own lawnmower, hedge clippersindependent contractor is not enough. They must
and weeding tools.actually be anindependent contractor.
Joe decides what time he arrives and how longIf you do misclassify an employee as an
the job takes (withinreasonable parameters). Youindependent contractor, youmust pay the IRS all
do not supervise Joe in his tasks ordictate to himback-taxes owed, plus interest, plus penalty
how they are to be done. Joe is an(12% - 35% of the total tax bill).
independentbusinessperson and you treat himAlso, you expose yourself to an increased risk of
accordingly. The final productis either to yourstate audits whenyour terminated independent
satisfaction or it isn't. When he's finished, youcontractor files for unemploymentbenefits. Never
payhim if you're satisfied with the end result andmind that you and your independent
you don't pay him ifyou're not.contractorintended that there be no employer
Contrast this with an employer/employeeemployee relationship, many'sthe disgruntled
situation. Let's sayyou own the business Joe'sindependent contractor who unilaterally decides
Gardening Service. You employthree employeetorecategorize the relationship as one of employer
gardeners to perform services for your business.employee whenthe spectre of unemployment
As the gardeners' employer, you pay them abenefits raises its pretty head. In suchsituations,
fixed wage and youwithhold taxes, unemploymentyou'd better be able to protect yourself by
insurance and various otherbenefits from theirproving thatthe arrangement was for an
wages to remit to the appropriateindependent contractor and not anemployee.
governmentagencies. In addition, you provide your=> Legal Liability
employees with the toolsand equipment theyUnlike an employee who is limited to workers'
need to perform their work. You tell them whattocompensationbenefits, an independent contractor
do and supervise them while they're doing it. Atcan sue you for negligence ifthey're injured on the
the end of thejob they get paid by you whetherjob. That's what liability insurance is forthough.